Welcome to NewlyOpened! We help you discover new restaurants in Lake Simcoe . Don't forget to bookmark NewlyOpened to stay updated on new openings!
See all new restaurants in Lake Simcoe .
Papa Luigi's Family Restaurant
Papa Luigi's Family Restaurant is a new restaurant in Lake Simcoe opened more than 6 months ago.
Established in 1973, we are a family-run restaurant in Sutton, Ontario (part of Georgina). Our MOST IMPORTANT goal is to serve you consistently fresh and delicious meals, both on site and by way of take-out. Based on our commitment to serving you only the best, WE BAKE all of our breads, baguettes and buns! All of our pastries and cookies are also baked at the MARKET STREET BAKERY, which we also own (and is located just around the corner). We serve breakfast, lunch and dinner, and any other meals during the course of the day you might be in the mood for. We WELCOME Vegans, Vegetarians & Pescatarians, + those who are on GLUTEN-SENSITIVE diets (the restaurant, as a whole, is not a gluten-free facility.) We look forward to serving you!
Location
117 High St, Georgina, ON L0E 1R0
You Might Also Consider
Lake Simcoe Arms Pub
Restaurant
"Good atmosphere Great patio space however it is right beside the road and can be noisy. Good service Good food. My only complaint is that the crudite that came with the fries was very..."
- Ankita Kumari
Anchor Family Restaurant
Family restaurant
"This is a 5-star rating for Jenny for her exceptional professionalism and customer service. She provided outstanding service with a smile, ensuring everything was perfect. The fresh salad and delicious..."
- Solukus com
Features
From the business
Service options
Frequently mentioned about
Featured User Reviews
The best place to go. Always great food, you never leave hungry. My favorite restaurant. A must have is Dave's Dill Pickle Pizza. Been going there for 35+ years.
December 7, 2024 on Google
We stumbled across this restaurant during the Whoville Event. I came with my three Children. The staff was so sweet and kind to my little ones. Such a wonderful family restaurant. To my complete surprise I could actually eat there! They accommodate vegan gluten-free And the food is good! I wasn’t left out eating only french fries I could eat with my children And it wasn’t processed junk. I will make the drive again for sure BONUS!!! The vegan gluten-free carrot cupcake was amazing!!!
November 24, 2024 on Google
I haven't had pizza from here in 7 years as I'd moved away from Sutton. I was driving through last evening and decided to stop by. The same people are there and OMG I think it tasted even better than before. The crust is amazing the bottom is chewy the outer edge crispy. They must use a special cheese because it's so chewy and delicious! Worth a drive off 48 or from Keswick. Thank you so much for such wonderful experience. I'll be back when I can.
August 30, 2024 on Google
I went here with my mom to try out and support the local restaurant. We came across this amazing family owned restaurant. We wanted to try the fish and chips so we ordered halibut piece with onion rings on the side and a drink. The service was great. Staffs was friendly, kind and quick. There was plenty of space when we went. Location is on high street so parking is on the street. Would highly recommend!
July 27, 2024 on Google
Fantastic spot. The atmosphere is very cozy. Portions are huge. Had a great time here with some friends.
June 16, 2024 on Google
At Papa Luigi's, you'll find a delicious blend of Italian flavors and fresh seafood. Papa's Pizza is a standout, with crispy crusts and a variety of toppings to choose from. For a lighter option, try the haddock with salad—it's fresh and flavorful. With friendly service and cozy ambiance, it's the perfect spot for a satisfying meal.
June 9, 2024 on Google
We stopped here for dinner and shared a few dishes. The Caesar salad was excellent, the fries were fresh cut, and the pepperoni pizza was so good. It was very cheesy with a nice, soft crust and a generous amount of pepperoni. The menu is big and will have something for everyone. The service was very friendly and attentive. I look forward to coming back!
August 5, 2023 on Google
The wife and I came in for the first time today. She ordered the halibut and chips she rated 9/10. I ordered a medium meat lovers pizza. A very tasty pizza, quality topping. Could skip rope with the mozorella. The dough was thick and chewy but light and fluffy at the same time rated 7.9/10 I highly recommend!
March 5, 2023 on Google
Hours
(905) 722-8822