Ever Fresh Pizza

Is just ok. Asked for extra sauce and wasn’t apparent. Minimal toppings and undercooked. Not sure I would order again.

January 4, 2025 on Google

Serves some of the best pizza I’ve ever had perfectly crispy crust, fresh toppings, and full of flavor. The staff are friendly, and the great atmosphere makes it a great spot.

October 23, 2024 on Google

I’ve lived in welland for almost a year now and I’ve been trying to find a good pizza place. Ever fresh is the best I’ve had. I’ve tried Luciano’s, Angelina’s, rose city, Antonio’s, and the Rex, and this place is better than all of them.

April 8, 2024 on Google

Pizza was good but it showed up only cut in one direction. That was a first... As well the pop temperature wise felt like it was sitting in someone's backseat of a car all afternoon. I usually like these guys and have ordered from them repeatedly. But what's going on this evening?. 🎊

March 14, 2024 on Google

We recently moved to Welland and are so happy to have found this pizza. The pizza is delicious, fresh, and you can’t beat the price! They are very generous as well, every time I ask for the wings to be a little extra saucy they have done this at no charge (I do this because we once got wings that were a little dry but still great tasting!) The only cons are: 1. The medium wing sauce sometimes is more like a mild - there may have been a mix up and we got some mild wings instead last time we ordered but they were still delicious! 2. The garlic bread isn’t great, it’s quite dry so we started to get the combo with wings instead of garlic bread. I’m not even going to take any stars away though because the pizza and wings are the most important part! We definitely recommend giving it a try!

June 20, 2023 on Google

Got the XL double pepperoni, it was hot and delicious when i picked it up and there were no complaints among us eating. The wings they sell are baked not fried but are pretty good anyways. The honey garlic wings were good but unfortunately the suicide wings were far from hot. They would barely classify as medium in my opinion. I would probably give these guys 5 stars if they revised their suicide wing recipe and made them proper hot. You shouldn't be able to crush a whole order of suicide wings in 5 mins. This place also smells like rubbing alcohol or vinegar inside, not that i really cared. One small gripe i have is that the sauce and cheese could have been a bit closer to the edge.

December 30, 2022 on Google

So I have gone to everfresh for almost 20 years maybe more! I'm a local wellander and let me tell you.... its sad to say but this will be the last time that I go :( the new owners have let the pizza slip :( the amazing lady that owned the shop before you could just taste the love and this sad mistake for a pizza now is just gunna slip away for me. I got hf way through the za befor I did make a judgment call but could tell almost right away just from the look that it was not the same pizza I had grown to love. I'm so sad to see the real everfresh go and no long be part of my pizza night with my family. 💔

June 13, 2022 on Google

Pizza is not great. Sparse toppings and the dough tastes like cardboard. Don’t order the hot Italian sausage, tastes freezer burned.

April 16, 2021 on Google