Welcome to NewlyOpened! We help you discover new restaurants in Toronto. Don't forget to bookmark NewlyOpened to stay updated on new openings!

See all new restaurants in Toronto.
Uncle Tony's
Loading photos...

Uncle Tony's

Italian restaurant
3.6(635 reviews)
Closed
Today's hours: 12 - 10 PM

Uncle Tony's is a new restaurant in Toronto opened more than 6 months ago.

Serving delicious authentic Italian food in the heart of Toronto's vibrant St. Lawrence market neighborhood.

Loading photos...

Location

38 Wellington St E, Toronto, ON M5E 1C7

Features

Service options

Outdoor seatingDeliveryDine-in

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible seatingWheelchair-accessible entrance

Frequently mentioned about

tipshareaccordionmeatballsromanticmanagercutecandlephonerude

Featured User Reviews

Absolutely delicious Had all the vibes. Candle light dinner with Sinatra playing in the background. It’s a small cozy restaurant with only a few tables. The food was absolutely amazing The service was great Would have liked to have seen some mocktails or more non alcoholic options Over all 10/10 will definitely be back!

November 17, 2024 on Google

Uncle Tony’s is our favourite local spot for Italian. The service is amazing every time and they’re so friendly they make you feel like you’re at home. The food is delicious I go for pizza and pasta but every time I try something new it’s a win! It’s also much more affordable than some others in the neighbourhood. As a regular I can’t believe that there’s even one bad review. Those people must have been having a bad day.. Run don’t walk to Uncle Tony’s!!

November 14, 2024 on Google

We were passing by the restaurant on a nice warm night and liked the idea of sitting outside. However, I wish I had checked the Google reviews before going inside. We made sure to make it clear that we didn't want anything spicy since my husband is allergic. The meat and side vegetables were spicy. The mashed potatoes were tasteless. The risotto was okay. But the amount and quality were not worth the price. The staff was so unfriendly that we didn't bring it up. Won't come back again.

September 26, 2024 on Google

Servers were nice and good. Restaurant was clean But food quality really needs work Meatballs were dryer than an old grandpas foot. Pizza tasted like it was a frozen pizza (the cheese was weird) Given the location, I'm sure this restaurant gets a lot of traffic regardless and there may be some who are repeat customers for one or two dishes that are good- this might be making management complacent in their existing quality But I was a new customer and will probably never come back because of how disappointing my meal was. I'm only giving 2 stars because server was sweet.

September 24, 2024 on Google

We walked past Uncle Tony’s a couple of times and were intrigued by the cozy atmosphere of this dim lit restaurant. We ended up making a reservation for a special day. Despite the reservation and emphasis that this was an anniversary, we got seated at a random table and were convinced that they had made no specific arrangements. Aside from this the service was very kind and relatively fast. We ordered Nonna’s meatballs, a rustic pizza, spaghetti carbonara and a tiramisu. The Meatballs were good, I really enjoyed the Rustic Pizza, the carbonara wasn’t the best, tiramisu was ok but it was a bit dry. We sat and watched the fountain at the Berczy Park after dinner and had a great time. So I’m adding the location in the pros list.

September 16, 2024 on Google

We ordered the pesto chicken pasta and chicken parmigiana. This is the best tasting Italian food in a while. Everything was seasoned great and portions are good. Way better than chain restaurants. 👍🏽👍🏽 glad stubbled appon here.

June 30, 2024 on Google

We had a visit where we could not eat. we were eagerly waiting for our order, but the owner came and said that there is a five dollar surcharge if we order only one item. only one of us was hungry and the person did not want to eat much so we ordered one pizza. The owner mentioned that he would put a surcharge if we do not order the second item. He was little rude, so we decided to get up and go to a nearby place called pico. Pico was much cheaper much faster and had a great options and taste. The amazing pizza you see is from PICO

June 14, 2024 on Google

Good- but not great. My wife/I have passed Uncle Tony’s many times on our walks as we live in the area. But I believe they are worthy of their 3.7 ⭐️ Google rating & I would say my rating/review would be the same… The pizza/pasta was good-but not great. I’ve had better Italian meals at several other Italian restaurants in the city with much bigger portions as well for same price point at Uncle Tony’s. Vagabondo comes to mind instantly. They do not have a cocktail menu when I asked for one. The server/manager said “I could make anything you want!” That’s great but I like to see ingredients of said cocktails & of course the price point as well. It doesn’t really help me when he says he can make “anything!” The tiramisu dessert was very good though. My wife said it was the best part of the meal. The ambience & atmosphere are also very relaxing/nice. But that’s only part of the experience. The food/service is what really makes the restaurant great! Again- good but not great…

November 17, 2023 on Google