Tony G’s Pizzeria

We are from out of town but decided to grab pizza from here since we would be in Hamilton. I called earlier in the day and ordered for pickup for dinner time. It was SO good. The crust/pizza dough was cooked to perfection, the sauce is amazing and exactly the type of pizza sauce I love. Also to add the service is great. Tony G is a great guy, the customer service is amazing. I wish we lived closer as it would be our go to spot but we'll definitely grab it any time we're in town. 100% recommend.

January 5, 2025 on Google

Finally made it over early enough to get a pizza and I was not disappointed. Walked in, ordered a medium new york pepperoni and it was ready to walk out with in 15 mins. Although it was ice cold by the time I got it home on the bus, I dug right in without reheating and it was still perfect. The medium is also a very good size and was only just over 20 bucks, very reasonable. I noticed they also have a fair amount of dine-in space available. Will definitely return to try some other pies in the future!

January 5, 2025 on Google

Tony G's is one of the best NY style pizzas I have ever had! Tony is super friendly and personable. He really takes pride of his work and rightfully so! Their garlic dip is to die for as well! We have a friend who is mildly allergic to garlic and even he couldn't stop eating the dip even though he knows he will be paying for it after 😅. It's just THAT good. This is a photo dump of some of Tony's pizzas that we have tried (and remembered to take a photo of). At this point, I feel like we have tried all of his pizzas at least once and kept going back for the ones we like the most!

January 3, 2025 on Google

Super duper delicious cheese slices! Epically cheesy, with just the perfect level of greasiness you want in an authentically floppy NY style slice of za. There's enough cheese on a single slice to keep you full all day!!!!! Amazing!!!!! You can tell the owner is deeply invested in making the best pizza, wanting you to love it as much as he loves making it!

December 28, 2024 on Google

I haven’t slept in weeks… I lay in bed and stare at my ceiling thinking about how people can live their entire lives without trying this pizza. I’ve had a lot of pizza in my day and this is the best pizza I’ve ever had without a doubt in my mind. This wasn’t my first time going and won’t be my last. Shoutout to the owner Charlie too he’s a great dude that must be protected at all costs!

December 28, 2024 on Google

Walked by and tried their pepperoni slice on a whim. Now a few weeks later I have to avoid walking by because I must stop for a slice every time. Really great pizza that strikes the balance between high quality cheese and fresh and crisp crust. In my opinion the best pizza in Hamilton.

October 27, 2024 on Google

Incredible attention to detail & fresh ingredients. Every flavor comes through in the best way possible. The size of each slice is very generous this is especially appreciated at a time where shrinkflation has become a daily issue. Some of the best pizza we've ever had. 💯 going back!

September 10, 2024 on Google

My mom and I visited for the first time today after a short drive from Cambridge, and it was absolutely worth it. The staff who welcomed us were friendly and knowledgeable. The owner, Charlie, was extremely kind and walked us through their different pizzas and explained what would travel best back to Cambridge with us. We ended up getting a large “Instagram” special (half Pepperoni, half Bronx) and a medium classic cheese (which we ordered late and still got super quickly), and all three were absolutely delicious. The classic cheese was the favourite. I couldn’t even get pictures of the full pies because we dove in so quickly. If I could give more than 5 stars I would. We will definitely be back many, many times.

August 18, 2024 on Google