The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria

A truly amazing experience at this pizzeria.🍕 A true pizza connoisseur will taste and feel the aged dough, and fresh ingredients and subtle nuances of flavour. 😋👌 We ordered the Classic Margherita and Sausage and Onion. The staff is super friendly and warm. Simran is a gem. 💎 Best regards.

August 12, 2024 on Google

Fourth Man in the Fire is quite honestly the best pizzeria in Toronto. Not only is all the food on the menu phenomenal (look at this donut tower!), the service is hard to beat. I had my birthday party there last weekend and Sim made the whole process a breeze. She was a pleasure to work with and knew exactly how to host a great party from start to finish, even down to packing take home boxes for all the guests. Everyone had an amazing time, thanks to Sim and all of the friendly staff. I’d highly recommend hosting any event here! 🥳

August 6, 2024 on Google

From the moment I walked in until the time I left, I enjoyed my experience here. The service is 10/10 and just as good as the food. I came from Scarborough and I felt it was worth the drive. I will probably dine in next time but I took it to go.

July 15, 2024 on Google

Hubby and I had our first experience today. Whomever your front staff was she was so welcoming, kind and efficient! I grew up in this area in the 70’s and we chatted about that too! The pizza was phenomenal,crispy bottom thin and passed the fold test lol. Toppings were fresh and vibrant. We ordered half dozen donuts to go and those were fantastic! Will definitely come again. The star of today was your front end staff who managed everything on her own so well..

July 11, 2024 on Google

Biased review based on my experience as of June 30th. We were a group of four, and we ordered: 1. Mozzarella Sticks 2. Vegetarian Pizza The ambiance and setup of the place were beautiful. The satirical celebrity pictures with autographs were brilliant. Unfortunately, it was breezy, so we decided to sit outside, but then it started drizzling—one of those summer days. Regarding the food, the mozzarella sticks were tasty. The 18-inch pizza was more than enough for the four of us. The taste was great, and the pizza was super fresh. We loved it. The staff was polite, gentle, and welcoming. Their smile was very warm and comforting. It was a good experience . I would definitely recommend this place.

July 1, 2024 on Google

If there was higher than a 5 star rating, this place would definitely get it! If you’re looking for an authentic flavours, real fresh ingredients and the most genuine customer service, this is your sign to visit Fourth Man In The Fire! Vanessa and Sim treated us with the utmost kindness from the moment we walked in, recommended some menu options and had us leaving with the biggest smiles on our face. By far one of the best dining in customer service experiences and a cute atmosphere for a date or a spontaneous pizza craving. Don’t forget their large variety of donuts upon entering. This is my new top pizza place. Thanks for the amazing time, we’ll be returning soon!

June 30, 2024 on Google

We had ordered the pizza once and loved it. This time we decided to go to the restaurant for a lil date night. It was a rainy Friday, we got seated right away, Z was helping us and he had great suggestions. We ordered the family and friends deal, which is UNBEATABLE - 59.99 for a 18” pie, 2 appetizers and 4 drinks. Z recommended us the BBQ chicken pizza which was 10/10! Considering it was a Friday and this place is so busy, the pie got a lil delayed which is no issue at all considering that the vibe there is so nice, and we had appetizers. Z and Sim (which we even joked could be the owners and siblings) made sure to check on us regularly and gave us two donuts to try for the wait. The donuts were made to perfection - the cherry one was my favourite, it was not oily, not super sweet but super delicious! Furthermore, we have multiple allergies, and they made sure to be extra careful when it comes to that. This is so important to us and it allows people with allergies to enjoy delicious food outside of their house!! Thanks Sim and Z for the amazing service! The food was already a 10/10 but the service was simply out of this world! Definitely recommend it.

June 24, 2024 on Google

The best sub in Toronto. I have been on the hunt for a quality sub and I can finally say I found it. This spot is the real deal with their freshly baked bread, fresh ingredients and the sub is compiled with excellence. The food is delicious and the staff are very friendly. When I ordered I was given a heads up that my food will take 30 minutes which I was perfectly fine with. On my way out I was given a complimentary box of donuts which was exceptionally nice of them. I had the donuts when I got home and they are mouthwatering.

June 3, 2024 on Google