Prince Street Pizza

Prince Street Pizza is the Toronto outpost of the famous New York City shop. The square slice was great, crispy and light my family really enjoyed it. It's nice to be able to get comparable New York pizza without having to travel.

January 5, 2025 on Google

Their pizza is so crispy and soft at the same time! Highly recommend eating it right away while it’s warm! The servers are super nice and friendly too!

December 29, 2024 on Google

How do I add more stars? No wonder this place makes all the lists of top/iconic NY pizza places. Holy spicy pepps Batman!! The spicy Soho Square is just freaking awesome. The meat lovers was great. The fancy prince was good, and the vodka one was a bit too salty imo. This place and Descendants = the king and queen of pizza in town. The crust is good, the sauce amazing, and those little grease filled Thick-ass pepperonis are to die for, I love when they have that little crispy edge too. Speaking of grease.. make sure you have lots of napkins... The squares are a bit on the greasy side, but for some people (like me) that's a good thing. The standard wedge shape seemed much less greasy, but those thick squares are so worth it.

October 26, 2024 on Google

Located on the outside edge of the southeast corner of The Well, Prince Street Pizza is well worth the wait and satisfies the pizza cravings. Customers may need to wait about 20-30 minutes for their order as there is usually a line-up. The establishment features a limited number of outdoor seats, which can fill up quickly. Their menu features a lot of options, catering to various tastes. During our experience, we ordered the Spicy Spring pizza with its generous portion of pepperoni. It was a flavourful choice and delicious. The whole pie is divided into eight rectangular slices, with two slices being quite filling alone. It's worth noting that the pizza is slightly oily, so make sure to grab some napkins and consider requesting a takeout box for leftovers or sharing with friends. The staff were very friendly and accommodating, even when we arrived near closing time.

October 21, 2024 on Google

Average New York style pizza at best - kinda mid, the NOT ranch sauce was just okay too, not too great. I think there’s better pizza places in Toronto. Very thin crust too - definitely need some more sauce. We tried the OG/ classic cheese and the ricotta and olive green one (can’t remember the name) the classic cheese was probably a 7/10 and ricotta one was 6 at best.

September 19, 2024 on Google

Just a quick place to get a decent slice of pizza. Crust was thin and crisp, sauce was okay though not exceptional, and the cheese was gooey and on point. You're not coming for the service, so excuse the staff being curt. Outside seating only, and could do with more active cleaning of the bins, but honestly, if you complain about that, you're at the wrong pizza spot.

August 18, 2024 on Google

We have been to the New York location last week, it’s not the same but still a good slice! I would prefer if my pizza was in the oven for a bit longer, next time I will ask for mines to be well done. We got the sunset slice, meat lover and the spicy pepperoni. I recommend the spicy pepperoni!

August 11, 2024 on Google

Came back in August, the pizza ruined my pizza cravings. It tasted stale, not fresh! A total waste of money! The girl who was helping acted very rude and impatient! This was August 26, at 12:34 noon time! This comment was from May: The pizza tasted amazingly delicious! Service was nice. A very small place with huge lineups when there.

June 18, 2024 on Google