Welcome to NewlyOpened! We help you discover new restaurants in Toronto. Don't forget to bookmark NewlyOpened to stay updated on new openings!
See all new restaurants in Toronto.Pizzaiolo
Pizzaiolo is a new restaurant in Toronto opened more than 6 months ago.
Fresh. Authentic. Made with Care. At Pizzaiolo, we’ve spent four generations perfecting the art of pizza-making. With organic ingredients where it matters most, and our signature fresh, never-frozen sauce and dough, every pizza is made fresh daily with love. Whether you need delivery, takeout, or a quick slice, we make it easy to enjoy The Pizzamaker’s Pizza.
Location
51 Underhill Dr, North York, ON M3A 1J2
Features
Service options
Accessibility
Frequently mentioned about
Featured User Reviews
Our go to pizza place everytime me and my son visits the eye doctor. He would say.. "daddy i want pizza" everytime we pass by the place. He loves the cheese pizza. Pizza tastes good. The texture is just right.
November 14, 2024 on Google
It took a bit to get the cook time just right, but now, perfect pizza everytime!! Keep up the great work 10/10.
November 11, 2024 on Google
3 stars because usually pizziolo is my go to spot for chain pizza in the GTA and I give it nothing but love. Recently had a negative experience at this location, made me think I feel asleep and woke up on April 1st when I opened the pizza box and saw a soggy pie staring back at me. I ordered banana peppers because I was looking for a little stank to help clear my sinuses and there was literally 3 little peppers staring back at me. To make it worse when I lifted the slice to take a bite the pizza was so soggy I felt like I was holding a wet wash clothe. Come on, let’s make pizza great again and make sure this doesn’t happen.
September 5, 2024 on Google
This is the first time I have ordered from Pizzaiolo. I picked up the pizzas. The staff were friendly and welcoming. The pizzas were delicious and well made. I often make my own pizza and these pizzas tasted like pizzas I would make with my homemade ingredients. The toppings were well-placed and generous. Lots of toppings as you can see in the photos. I ordered the Gianni Ola, and Capone pizzas, under the ‘meat’ section of their website. Gianni Ola as described on their website ‘Real Canadian Bacon, Organic Fresh Mushrooms, Dry Cured Pepperoni, Mozzarella Cheese and Pizzaiolo Tomato Sauce’. The Capone is described as ‘Oven-Roasted Chicken Breast, Organic Fresh Mushrooms, Roasted Red Peppers, Parmigiano Cheese, Mozzarella Cheese and Pesto Sauce (Nut Free)’. I loved the pesto base and overall flavour. I highly recommend Pizzaiolo. Side Note: I tried to place an online order but the ‘Underhill’ location was not on the list of locations, so I telephoned them with my order. Cheers!
July 28, 2024 on Google
I really like their pizzas, the website is easy to use. I usually get the pickup special, thin crust, peperoni, mini or regular both good, haven't tried shredded pepperoni, and I get the fresh garlic, crushed chili and oregano. Really good. I can place my order walk my dogs down there and usually it's ready in about 15 to 20 mins when I arrive. Unfortunately I tried to eat it on the way home and my dog snatched a piece. He only stole a peperoni but it fell on the ground so I had to toss it.
May 25, 2024 on Google
Had the most amazing calzone ever. Baked to perfection and stuffed full. Great flavors, crust is crispy, chewy, garlicy perfection.
May 13, 2024 on Google
Have to say one of the best pizzas I've had. the Underhill location is great and the pizza is beyond good . Great addition to the area. Update I love love their pizza tastes amazing . Never a disappointment. Highly recommend
October 22, 2023 on Google
I’m so glad we finally got a Pizzaiolo location in our neighbourhood. We placed an order for a gluten-free Spinotta just under half an hour before closing time on a whim, but it turned out to be a great decision! The pizza was baked to perfection with generous amounts of toppings! The staff/manager was courteous and prompt. Will definitely frequent this location for their amazing service and hospitality.
July 31, 2023 on Google
Restaurant Guides for You
Get warmed up this winter with authentic Sichuan Restaurant in Toronto: Hot Spicy Spicy Chinese Restaurant
1/18/2025
Ever been on the hunt for that perfect spot that makes your taste buds dance with joy during winter? This hidden gem in North York has been serving up some amazing Sichuan cuisine for the past 20 years since 2005.
Top 10 BEST new Restaurants in Scarborough - January 2025 Edition
1/8/2025
Looking for awesome new places to eat in Scarborough? I've checked out some of the newest restaurants that opened since Fall 2024. There are some seriously cool spots you need to try. From amazing Indian food to Vietnamese pho that'll warm you up on cold winter days, here's my guide to the best new restaurants in Scarborough right now.

GST Tax Break Items List for Restaurants
1/5/2025
There is a temporary GST/HST break on certain items from December 14, 2024, to February 15, 2025 in Canada. During the tax break, no GST or HST (whichever applies in your province or territory) will be charged on food and beverages served at restaurants and other eating establishments. Here is the GST/HST tax break item list for restaurants and other eating establishments.
Hours
(416) 447-4900