Pizza On Fire

Best pizza I’ve ever had! You won’t be able to have any other after this. And the owner is so kind so i love that I’m supporting small businesses too. I ordered the Hawaiian but everything is good there!

December 23, 2024 on Google

Great-tasting pizzas. Ordered the Philly steak and the steak slices are thinly-sliced but adequately seasoned. The Margherita is also amazing, filled with sweet, juicy tomatoes. The Tandoori pizza is another winner but can be a bit too salty. And customer service is excellent, Baker will explain the ingredients and how your pizza is made. Pizza on Fire is worth a visit- go and give it a try.

December 15, 2024 on Google

The Tandoori Chicken pizza was amazing--filling, delicious, practically overflowing with perfectly seasoned chicken and the avocado surprised me with its buttery goodness! The Eggplant and Zucchini on the Garden pizza was sautéed perfectly to enhance their inherent flavors. The food was well worth the price, especially due to the value they deliver. I'll be back!

December 5, 2024 on Google

Very likely the best pizza in Scarborough! You can tell the ingredients they use are fresh and their pizza is delicious. Pretty good value as well. Their service is also great, the owner and staff are really nice, both over the phone and in person. Highly recommended!

November 11, 2024 on Google

Finally got to experience Pizza On Fire after hearing a lot of good things about this place. The pizza exceeded my expectations and I definitely be coming back to order more. They don’t skimp on the ingredients and the pizza was cooked just right.

October 3, 2024 on Google

I LOVE these guys!!! Ever since I tried this spot I could never go anywhere else for pizza again. The service is absolutely amazing. As well as the food, speaks for it self. I called to make an order today however forgot they wernt opened. The man answered and said we will be there soon so I apologize and was about to hang up. The gentlemen then reassured me saying it was OK and would gladly take my order over the phone while he was on his way to the shop and the first thing he would do is make my order. At the exact estimated time he said it was ready. Seriously love these guys. I almost wanna gate keep because this place is that good. Hope this place grows to its fullest potential!!

September 23, 2024 on Google

First time ordering from here and I must say that it is a 10/10. We ordered the Hawaiian pizza, Arrabiata pasta, and seafood pasta. All of them are very flavorful and well seasoned. The pizza was cooked very well, the top part where the pineapple and ham were are slightly crunchy from the baking, a nice char to it, also of course the crust was nice and crunchy while the dough was cooked properly and fluffy, the pastas are nicely done and properly seasoned. Hands down I will be ordering again and will try different options.

September 8, 2024 on Google

Decided to check this place out after all the great reviews. Let me break it down. This is one of the best pizzas you can buy. If you are a pizza connoisseur this is for you. It’s not cheap BUT one large pizza will easily and I mean EASILY fill up two people. With leftovers! The toppings are quality, they aren’t cheap with the cheese and the crust is baked to perfection. The best way I can describe this pizza is a cross between deep dish and Chicago style. So hearty and filling. Enjoy.

June 29, 2024 on Google