Welcome to NewlyOpened! We help you discover new restaurants in Whitby. Don't forget to bookmark NewlyOpened to stay updated on new openings!
See all new restaurants in Whitby.
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza is a new restaurant in Whitby opened more than 6 months ago.
At Papa Johns Pizza in Brooklin, ON, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Brooklin pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Brooklin or stop by 72 Baldwin Street for carryout to order the best pizza in Brooklin, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Location
72 Baldwin St Unit 103, Brooklin, ON L1M 0M2
You Might Also Consider
Brooklin Pub
Bar & grill
"Place is huuge, lots of tvs.. friendly staff.. good place to watch some sports. Tried the wings. It was pretty good, really liked the sauce."
- Sheldon Norman
Corrados Restaurant & Bar
Italian restaurant
"Lovely restaurant with delicious Italian menu options. The menu has a wide variety of appetizers, pizzas, salads, pastas, and other mains. The pizzas and pastas are specially good, as well..."
- Mariam Kubba-Martino
Features
Service options
Accessibility
Frequently mentioned about
Featured User Reviews
I ordered the gluten free pizza which cost $20.99 and it was awful.. it was burnt and the dough tastes old and not flavourful.. also I paid for extra cheese and not sure how much extra I actually got. My husbands regular pizza was cooked perfectly amd he says it tasted great. I am really disapointed with the gluten free pizza especially because I paid a lot for it. Would not reccommend. The delivery was quick and the driver was really nice and followed instructions.
November 19, 2024 on Google
i ordered papa Johns pizza 2 times and this is how I felt! I think the pizza was a nice taste, it was fresh and hot but the sauce has a sweet taste to it. The garlic pretzel bread things were amazing. Such good taste, and perfect amount of garlic. That is something I do recommend for a nice family dinner.Although The service was good nothing to complain about but nothing to say either. And the atmosphere was okay, pretty nice area just a bit busy for me. Personal I think this is just a good place for a quick take out spot for you and your family/friends and kid friendly spot for your kids to go get some food. but not my go to spot.
October 1, 2024 on Google
How is this location's pizza so much better than the one closer to me? I thought that they all use the same recipe and ingredients? I ordered exactly the same way as I usually do. I only gave 4 stars as I'm now miffed that I won't be able to enjoy my local pizza anymore. Hope my travels take me to Brooklin more often.
September 13, 2024 on Google
Papa John’s is excellent for take out. The pizza was ready on time , hot and had a perfect, crispy crust with fresh, flavourful toppings. My new go-to for a quick and tasty pizza! Would recommend.
August 9, 2024 on Google
Have ordered pizza from this place and had been great with plenty of topping. Ordered on yesterday with 4 toppings and was a total disappointment. Could not see the topping and crust was not fresh. Seemed like I got a premade pizza. If this is the future the pizzas I will not be going there
June 18, 2024 on Google
I have been ordering from this location for years and was very impressed. The pizza is always hot, fresh, and delicious. The crust is perfectly crispy, and the toppings are generously applied.The staff is really friendly. I highly recommend this Brooklin Papa John's!
December 18, 2022 on Google
Second time I’ve ordered here. Gave them the benefit of the doubt last time and tried them again. Just as disappointing so I Wont be returning and cannot recommend. The sauce and cheese and pepperoni don’t taste good. Breadsticks were over done & on top of it all they didn’t give me the 2 sauces I paid for.
February 2, 2021 on Google
Restaurant looks great. Staff are super friendly. I really, really wanted to love it but for my taste, the pizza sauce was a little sweet. I can see why lots of people love it and the ingredients tasted fresh. Just a little sweet for my taste. Worth another try for sure and I applaud their effort and friendliness.
January 10, 2021 on Google
Hours
(905) 439-4458