North of Brooklyn Pizzeria

I’m pretty particular when it comes ones to pizza, looking for that authentic crust and cheese and sauce. I always order a cheese pizza when I want to test how good the pizza is and I have to say they did it for me for the most part! However, I would say the crust could have had a little more weight/bite. I felt I needed a few slices before I felt good.

December 29, 2024 on Google

I had never been to this location, but it was excellent. The crust was crisp, yet had the perfect chewiness. My first choice for NY style pizza in the GTA.

December 15, 2024 on Google

It had an overpowering rosemary taste which surprisingly, I wasn’t a fan of. (I do love rosemary). The cheese was fine but it reminded me of an elevated ristorante pizza. I did enjoy it and I would return if I was in the area because it was simple and still delicious but it was not the best margarita pizza I ever had. We enjoyed it fresh while we were there. No seats but we didn’t mind.

December 1, 2024 on Google

Recently dropped by to grab two pizzas for a get together, knew that North of Brooklyn was well hailed. Went in and ordered the NY Cheese and Vodka Verde and was out in less than 15 minutes. The pizzas are excellent NY style pies hitting all the important qualities: crisp well baked crust; thin with a bit of droop; and seasoned very well. The Vodka Verde was particularly a great combo pizza. Also do not sleep on their dipping sauces, the garlic is deeply savoury and stands apart from the usual pizza regulars. The donair sauce completely surprised and might just be the perfect pizza dip, how have I not seen this elsewhere?

October 27, 2024 on Google

Ordered the truffle pizza and it hit the spot!! My sister and I devoured this pizza - you can taste the truffle and the crust was thin and well made. Pizza wasn't too greasy either - would definitely come back! Note that this location is takeout only.

September 25, 2024 on Google

We ordered online for take out. The online ordering process was easy and the pizza was ready in just over half an hour. The pick up process was very quick and efficient: we were in and out of the restaurant within a minute. The staff was quick and friendly. We tried the pepperoni pizza. The toppings were generous and the pizza was delicious. The crust was well made with a crunchy, yet chewy texture. Overall, not the best pizza I've ever had, but still very good. We enjoyed our experience.

August 11, 2024 on Google

Call in advance to order before you go, as they get a lot of orders! We called to make an order for dinner, and they mentioned it would take 1 hour before it is ready. Great takeout spot if you’re looking for thin crust pizza with a few toppings. The crust was very thin, chewy, and overall very delicious. Garlic knots were OK - there is flavour but their pizza was definitely the highlight. No seating available. This is purely a takeout spot.

April 27, 2024 on Google

Amazing thin crust pizza! We placed an order by phone for four pies about 2 hours before we needed it on a Saturday evening. They told us that at the earliest they can make it for us in 20 minutes. We had to call a few times to make modifications such as how many slices to cut the pieces into and which pies we wanted and they were very patient with us over the phone. When we arrived for pickup there was a short lineup of people waiting to pick up their pizzas and it did get a bit chaotic. They ended up giving us two mistake pizzas for free but it was just a bonus for us I guess. Our favorite is definitely the truffle shuffle, but all the pizzas used high quality ingredients and had a thin crispy crust, you can't go wrong with any of them. Friends and I really appreciate that they have vegetarian options. There is no dine in at this location, and there is a small flight of stairs to get to the pizzeria. It is take out only. One small washroom available. I recommend that you order ahead of time over phone or the website instead of walking in because it can get crazy.

January 22, 2024 on Google