North of Brooklyn Pizzeria

The garlic knots and the pizzas were fantastic! We got the large killer Bee, truffle shuffle, and NY cheese with sausage and bacon. Everything tasted amazing!

December 6, 2024 on Google

Such a vibrant and welcoming establishment ! Easily some of the best pepperoni pizza I’ve had in the city. I have no idea what they use to make their garlic dip, but it was so good I ordered 2. I definitely see why Dave Portnoy rated this the best pizza in Toronto ! Definitely recommend trying it out, you will not be disappointed !

November 5, 2024 on Google

My always go to place if i am craving for a nice slice. Truffle Shuffle and Vodka Verde two of my favs pizzas . And lets not forget about their fresh and yummy Caesar salad . North of Brooklyn never disappoints me :))

October 30, 2024 on Google

I recently visited North Brooklyn Pizzeria, and while the food was good, the service was incredibly disappointing. We were ignored by the staff for a while and handed the menus way too late. When we ordered wine, it came in a can, which was unexpected, and they served it in a short glass instead of a proper wine glass. The tables, plates and glasses were so dirty I don’t know how they pass the health inspection. This really took away from the dining experience. It's a shame because the food had potential, but the poor service left a bad taste.

September 14, 2024 on Google

We ordered a large Truffle Shuffle pizza for three adults, but it turned out to be a bit rich, leaving us with about two slices leftover. It might be better to get two small pizzas with different flavors instead. The large size is huge! The dough is delightfully chewy and flavorful, and if you like thin crust pizza, this is a must-try. During the day, it's self-service, but they offer table service during certain evening hours. What i ordered: - Truffle Shuffle Pizza ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Parking: Street Park or Private parking behind the building

August 27, 2024 on Google

This place is a true gem. One of the best pizzas money can buy. We ordered the signature kale and bacon pizza. A really well executed dish. We ordered two brios and two garlic dipping sauces as well. The atmosphere inside is really neat and the finish carpentry is top notch. They have giant bay windows and a lot of cool wall art of different pizzerias from NYC North of Brooklyn is inspired by. The service is fast, attentive, and very polite. Love that they do sit down here. Amazing spot!

August 20, 2024 on Google

I LOVE North of Brooklyn pizza especially this location. No matter what day, time or how many times I've gone they have always been consistent when it comes to freshness, ingredients, and service. The pizza is always perfection with a crunchy, thin crust and amazing toppings. If you have not tried their kale and bacon pizza that’s a must. It is my go to and my absolute favorite along with their in-house made garlic, dipping sauce. I have tried a few of their other pizzas at some of the other locations, but I gotta say kale and bacon always steals the show. The staff is always kind, friendly and pleasant. this location is very modern and fresh with beautiful pictures on the wall, paying homage to some of the first best known pizzaerias.

August 12, 2024 on Google

Everything was great! Can't go wrong with a Classic Pepperoni. Killer Bee was the other one we tried, and if you like sweet and savory, I would go for that. The hot honey is great, Creamy Garlic was close to a dressing vs a dip in terms of consistency, Donaire dip was good as well and not too sweet. Only gave it a 4 rating due to the price. I totally get it that it's Toronto and everything is expensive, but 2 medium pizzas and a side of Garlic knots, with tax and tip was close to $80 and that wasn't dining in either. Great pizza either way, I can see why it's one of the faves in the city.

June 5, 2024 on Google