Nonno Crupi's Pizza

Old school NY style pizza in Ballantrae (north of Stouffville) .. wonderful friendly staff, delivery times are how long it takes to make your pie and get it to you..crust is amazing sauce has that little bit of TANG and the crunch .. yep Dave Portnoy JUST ONE BITE would be proud ! 8.9 from me

December 27, 2024 on Google

One of the best veal sandwiches you can have in the GTA! Sandwich is very big and the toppings and sauce are delicious! Family run pizza shop that’s a true hidden gem. The pizza here is also great and you get great value for the price. Highly recommended for anyone in Stouffville or driving on Highway 48.

November 13, 2024 on Google

I grew up in Stouffville in the 60s/70s and we were blessed with Gulios pizza, best thin crust, real Italian pizza ever. I have been living back here several years now and always drive by Nonna Crupi's on a regular basis. I finally tried it tonight as from what I hear their veal on a bun is amazing. I'm not a fan of their pizza "one bite everyone knows the rules" I'm ½ way through my first slice (basic pepperoni and mushroom). The crust is thick and very tough and by the time I got home with it, 10 minutes drive it was cold. Not my thing but it may appeal to some.

October 9, 2024 on Google

It's the best pizza place in the GTA. We've been ordering pizzas from Nonno Crupi for over 6 years. Owners are super friendly and honest people. The pizzas are always loaded with fresh toppings. The veal sandwiches are amazing, fluffy bun and a delicious sauce that ties everything together. When the food is this good, the price is just a number.

September 11, 2024 on Google

We went out of our way to try this place as they have a lot of great reviews. It’s in north Stouffville so it’s a bit of a trek it well worth it. Definitely the best pizza in Stouffville. Service was good and they really pack the pizza with a lot of toppings. We had the Super Pizza, definitely recommend it. If you’re in the area you should try this place out over the main stream pizza brands.

September 10, 2024 on Google

Nanno Crupi’s Pizza is a hidden gem in the Stouffville Ballantrae community. Every time I order over the phone, they prepare the pizza piping hot and right on schedule. The crust is perfect, and the sauce is tasty, with generous toppings. Their pizza, especially party-size pizza, has never disappointed me. Whether it’s a group gathering or a cozy dinner, Nanno Crupi’s Pizza makes catering easier and more delightful. If you are craving pizza, Nanno Crupi is the place to go.

June 6, 2024 on Google

I cannot tell you how happy Nonno Crupi's Pizza makes me! When I moved to Stouffville from Toronto, my biggest fear was I would not find a decent Pizza place. Initially this was true, but eventually I stumbled upon Nonno Crupi's and my Pizza salvation! As a lifelong Pizza aficionado, I've generally eaten Pizza 1-2 times a week for the past 40+ years. As a result, I'm pretty resolute about what it is that makes good vs bad Pizza. Let me assure you that Nonno Crupi's checks all the right boxes! Crust is full without being too heavy or bready with just the proper amount of charring, the sauce has the right amount of tang without being too sweet or acidic and the toppings are all excellent quality. Best of all, they don't skimp on the cheese! Then there's the prices. Talk about great value on top of a great pie! You can spend almost twice as much at a chain places in town for Pizza only half as good as Nonno Crupi's. The Calzones are equally exciting with loads of whatever toppings you choose. I haven't tried the Veal sandwiches yet, but it's on my to do list and I can't wait as I've heard great things about them. Keep up the incredible work guys.

April 10, 2024 on Google

Honestly the best, most consistent pizza you will find. Always hot, fresh and full of flavour. Their wings are incredible too!

June 4, 2021 on Google