Mystery Wheel Pizza

Visited Mystery Wheel with my husband for the first time today. We started with a few slices to try, brought them back to our car and we were so in love with the slices, we went back in to try 2 more. The cheese, crust, toppings….EVERYTHING was to die for. Slices are $6-$7 but very much justified with the fresh ingredients and integrity that goes into each slice. Definitely a must visit in your near future. We can’t wait to go back!!!

January 4, 2025 on Google

Mystery Wheel Pizza is an absolute must try! After visiting today and purchasing their pizza, I can truly say that I will be a forever returning customer! It is soo exciting to finally have a pizza shop that knows how to make a proper pizza slice in the Town of Bowmanville!

January 4, 2025 on Google

I went to the Mystery Pizza Wheel in Bowmanville and had a slice of "The Red Pie," which, let me tell you, is the best pizza I’ve had in Ontario outside of Badiali’s in Toronto. The crust was perfect—crispy but soft, like a bread wizard conjured it... and the sauce, just wow it was like someone whispered secrets to a tomato before turning it into sauce. The toppings were spot-on, none of that over-the-top “pile it all on” nonsense. It’s so good, I’m starting to think they struck a deal with the devil, or at least a very skilled pizza maestro. If you’re within driving distance, you need to try it. If you’re not, move closer.

January 3, 2025 on Google

Took a detour off the 401 to try out Mystery Wheel Pizza. Planned to have a single slice and ended up trying them all! All slices were into the 9s for us on a 10 rating scale. Insanely good dough & crust Insanely good sauce & cheese Insanely good toppings Insanely friendly owners Great undercarriage and next to no flop! Highly recommend!

January 2, 2025 on Google

This pizza is honestly so good, not to mention the dip! Loved the crust and sauce! I got the pepperoni, onion and hot honey pie. My family raved about it and now we are all craving more. Lisa and Brandon, the owners, are so friendly and personable. Their shop is such a great vibe too. Highly recommend!

December 21, 2024 on Google

Super great new place. The taste of the pizza was amazingggg. Lots of variety to choose from and love the whole idea of the mystery wheel. Very creative. If I had one feedback to give, it would be to offer full pizzas for order. The pizza slice idea is cool but could tell they had been sitting out and was reheated and with that had the texture of next day pizza. A little bit stale but still amazing. I'd die to be able to order a full fresh pizza. I hope they consider this as a future option! A little pricey too for small thin slices.

December 18, 2024 on Google

This place is a great addition to the downtown. We tried the Olive + Onion and the Mystery slice (pepperoni, hot honey, stracciatella, basil) and both were excellent. The owners are lovely, the pizza's great and this is a really fun concept to have a rotating mystery slice to come back and try.

December 16, 2024 on Google

I really like this place! The flavours are excellent! We tried all 4 slices. My favourite slice is the Mystery special. The onion olive honey was also really good and you don’t miss the cheese, the fresh garlic gives it a lot of flavour. The dough is also a little different from slice to slice which I really enjoyed. The people are really nice. They seemed to really enjoy what they are doing and it shows. I only mention this because of the weather. It is best to eat in store. If you want to do take out the Mystery slice reheated the best.

December 12, 2024 on Google