Johnny's Pizza Orangeville

Great pizza 🍕, crispy yet soft, goey with just the right amount of grease. The wings are just how I like them, especially the Cajun ones. Thank you.

December 19, 2024 on Google

Honestly I called months ago to ask how much the lasagna was and how many people it would feed and the girl who answered the phone seemed like she hated her life, but this time I decided to try calling agian, the girl on the phone was happy to help me and when I went in to pick up my food she was nice and told me to have a nice night so with everything that has happened in the past I am happy to say I had a lovely experience, it's so great to see nice workers and eat great food aswell! Overall I'm happy and will be coming back very soon, thank you to the workers and Johnnys pizza!

December 15, 2024 on Google

Pizza quality has continued to decline since Covid. I used to absolutely love this pizza. I decided to try it out again hoping that things will have turn around ordered to large with extra cheese. Extra cheese is as definitely not added and the was so cooked that I dried out the pizza completely. Really miss what this place used to be.

December 13, 2024 on Google

Ordered an XL pepperoni to pick up at a specific time, got there and they forgot to make it, which happens, but then they overcooked it just shy of burning it. I decided to give them another chance and I find out they actually don’t even have XL pizzas, which makes sense since I suspected the first one I got was too small. I just don’t appreciate they weren’t honest about it the first time.

December 9, 2024 on Google

After not coming here for years I got a large one topping pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and 6 pops from pickup for 26.53 I was surprised by the price being so high as a one topping is 9.99 a three topping 14.99 so my question is why is it 26.53 seems way over priced. Will not return JOHNNYS DAYS ARE OVER as best pizza in orangeville. NO WONDER THEY ARE 4.0 OUTTA 5. Dominos is better and cheaper I used to love johnnys sad this occurred. It was a favorite spot at one time.

November 14, 2024 on Google

back in the early 90's there was a joint called airport pizza and they were rated the #1 pizza in canada: Me and my family were coming back from a fishing trip and we happened to chance upon this place. I still remember the intoxicating aroma wafting through the car as we drove home. I had my first mouthgasm, the savory cheese, the succulent pepperoni....I can recall the exact feeling i had to this day. So i was shook when a little hole-in-the-wall establishment rekindled those gastric recollections. When I ordered from Johnny's pizza for the first time, i had a Ratatouille moment (the one where Anton Ego has a flashback to his childhood when he first tastes the perfection of Remy's concoction), It made me remember what exquisiteness tastes like and transported me back 30 years to a place and time of innocence, a carefree existence and the novelty of first time experiences. " I will be returning to Johnny's soon, hungry for more. "

October 24, 2024 on Google

Great local pizza dive for pizza. We ordered ahead and picked up. The staff was quick and efficient and order was ready when we arrived. Pizza is good and service was great. Worth the visit and a return.

March 9, 2023 on Google

First time going and honestly best pizza I have ever had it has so much flavor and Its filling! Would 100% recommend and the wings were good!

March 14, 2020 on Google