Four Brothers Pizza

I don’t wanna hit a local place with a 3 star because I feel like the experience would’ve been better if I dined in. Pizza may have been more fresh dining in, rather than delivery. However the skulls, which I always wanted to try, were kinda disappointing. Not sure if this is usual, but they had this artificial taste and smell to them, as if you could still taste the device that gave them their weird shape. A fun gimmick, but something to just try once based off my experience. My main course was the Sweet Chilli Chicken pizza! This was unique and something I’d come back in person to try, if they offer slices. Insane costs for delivery … $60 for a small pizza, the smallest size of skulls, plus drink/dips. Skulls were not worth the $20 price, but the small pizza was worth the $15.

December 25, 2024 on Google

Pizza twirls: 9/10 - excellent , incredibly soft, chewy and flavorful. Would like to try the premium one day Pizza: 5/10 - just hits the spot but nothing more. Good sauce and cheese but bland, soft crust. Almost like a pita bread. Wings: 4/10 - not satisfying at all. Dry meat and thin, non crispy breading. I've had better grocery store wings from the freezer aisle. I did have takeout but I doubt having it in person would be much better. Not a lot of seating area and the food was still warm when I got home.

July 17, 2024 on Google

The pizza skulls are unique and quite good. Although I would say this place is way too pricey for a pizza joint. This place is known to get busy during weekends and fridays when people go clubbing or partying. They also got these comfy couches to eat at. Good drunk food for sure.

January 15, 2024 on Google

I ate a couple pizza skulls and rolls I ordered from ubereats before realizing the dough was very undercooked and raw in parts (I thought it was melted cheese). It was very tasty but now I have a horrible stomachache and have been incredibly bloated for over a day. I did receive a refund from ubereats but it is definitely not safe to eat until baked further or airfried. Onion rings and donuts were tasty however! Unfortunately though the taste is great, I do have to give 1 star for the inedible dough.

December 16, 2023 on Google

Absolutely Delectable!!!! NY style pizza with that homemade flavour touch! After a night of drinking and clubbing, four brothers just hit the spot. Cheesy, greasy but not to greasy, fresh and just the right amount of crust.. Four brothers well done 👏

October 9, 2023 on Google

Stuffed pizza skulls were delish! Crispy on the outside and cheesy gooey on the inside. Great location and loved the decor. Parking is available in front of the store as well which is very rare downtown.

May 26, 2023 on Google

Very very disappointed with Four Brothers Pizza. I called last week to place a large order to be ready for 11am today. We had an event at our office in North York, this location wouldn't deliver, so I came to pick these up on my own as we wanted the Pizza skulls for Halloween! I got there for 11, no one was picking up their phone. They called me at 11:20 and said I was able to come in to the store. The food was not ready. I waited until 12pm - they made me an hour late for our work event - no discounts for the inconvenience, hardly a sorry from any of the staff! Not only was this an hour late to be finished, the Pizza skulls were dilapidated and were not fully cooked! The pizza dough was still uncooked (attached picture). I now have to worry about our staff getting sick off of this and we spent almost $300 at your location. I called to let the store know about all of this and was told they needed to speak with their manager and no one returned my call. Update: Thank you to Farhad for reaching out below and hearing my concerns when I contacted him. Farhad, I appreciate the help and wish you and your business the best.

October 31, 2022 on Google

Culinary geniuses. Imagine, turning Pizza into a skull, absolutely genius. I was out and about in Toronto when I stumbled upon Four Brother's Pizza, I asked what was hot and they told me Pizza Skulls. I ordered six of these devious delights with the expectation that they would be flavorless balls of just sauce, and I'm glad I was wrong. The pizza skulls came out cooked perfectly, a golden brown exterior with a thin dough outer shell keeping hidde the sauce and cheese core. It was a nice treat, and surprise of flavour. Definitely a fun tourist food, and a food for after a night out. Recommend this place highly!

July 4, 2022 on Google