Fickle Pickle Restaurant

I had the absolute worst Experience at this diner that I’ve ever had in my entire life. Me and my friends waited over an hour to get food. They had one waitress running around serving 95% of the restaurant when they had three servers on staff and the other two were standing around like idiots and running around like a chicken with her head cut off, she was doing an absolutely amazing job but every other person in there was terrible. I will never be going back to this place in my entire life or ever again and they have lost so much money.

October 19, 2024 on Google

Came here in the summer (Canada Day) around 1:30pm and waitress told us to seat ourselves. We sat/waited for close to 10 minutes without service while other tables were eating their meals. Went to inquire and staff said they were closing and can't serve us. All the while, another couple just got seated and had to leave as well. I understand closing early on a holiday, but no one took responsibility or cared on why we were seated in the first place. Want to support local, but this place needs to get it together.

October 18, 2024 on Google

Had a really great brunch here today with a large family group. Great food, and good coffee. Pancakes were unbelievably good, and my son gave two hard earned thumbs up for the fish n chips. Would recommend for sure.

September 22, 2024 on Google

Visiting from Alberta, I was walking Main Street in lovely, charming Stouffville Ontario. I was looking for a restaurant with welcoming/“come in our doors” atmosphere. Fickle Pickle drew my attention. I didn’t pre-review the restaurant so I’d have a clean feel for my own review. I was immediately welcomed (by owner?) and seated; he checked the customers throughout the time I was here, very attentive. At one point a customer asked for a “real” coffee and this man grinned and said “just you wait” lol. The restaurant was clean, (as was the ladies washroom); the cooks wore hairnets. It was very busy at noon. Great to see this. The young lady that tended to me was very friendly and warm. Huge menu selections, I couldn’t help by commenting on this with her. She laughed. I ordered beef brisket, upgraded the au jus to gravy. The plate had good food placement, the fries were overflowing & amazing: crisp and flavourful, and when dipped into the amazing robust beef gravy even better! The beef brisket was also robust, flavourful, tender and aLOT on top of sesame seed buns. The portion offered was way more than I could eat. Also offered was a crisp, juicy pickle spear. Yum. My husband called while I was eating. We laughed as he had eaten here 6 years ago and the meal was memorable (beef liver and onions), THAT was quite a 👍🏻 all this time later. He even remembered the restaurant signage. My only regret is I had no room left for dessert. I say treat yourselves, come to Fickle Pickle, and try their eyeopening copious meal options. I highly recommend.

July 11, 2024 on Google

Loved the garlic bread, potatoes, and pork souvlaki and Greek salad. The chicken parmigiana, fries, and rice were good.

June 30, 2024 on Google

Not busy on a nice weekday afternoon. Food is ok, no surprise, big portion. Affordable price.

May 26, 2024 on Google

I must say, im quite impressed with Stouville food options! Back in our area of Markham, its more of a hit or miss, fast food franchises and street parking is a pain. We would definitely be willing to make the drive to Fickle Pickle again! Wonderful service, reasonable prices, and large portions! We ordered a hot chocolate (comes with whipped cream), chicken soulvaki dinner (comes with garlic bread and salad), all day breakfast steak and eggs, and kids penne pasta. Everyone greatly enjoyed their food and the only leftover was pasta because it was such a big portion for my toddler (he still liked it days later!). This place is spacious and can easily fit many groups. They have high chairs. Looking forward to another visit :) Thanks for a great time :)

February 20, 2024 on Google

We dined at the Fickle Pickle for the first time and had a lovely experience. The food is nothing fancy, but it was a great casual spot for an affordable “diner style” meal. I was a bit cautious of our choice due to the many negative reviews posted recently, but am glad we decided to come anyways! Our server and initial hostess were both very pleasant, attentive and helpful. We dined as a group of 5, off-hours during a weekend afternoon. Were seated at a clean and large table and were 1 of about 3 other tables in service at the time. The food took some time to arrive, but with staff shortages and not being in a rush, it wasn’t a bother at all. Food was good, not great, but exactly what we were craving for a casual afternoon. Thanks for a great meal - all for less than $110 including tax and tip!

January 14, 2023 on Google