Carson's Pizzeria Niagara Falls

So disappointed. We ordered tonight because our kids have it at school and they asked for it. The pizza was thin as cardboard and tasted as such. The wings barely had any sauce on them and so were dried out that they were too tough to eat. The fries were even overcooked.

December 5, 2024 on Google

Oh boy did I make a mistake. I ordered from here based on a photo off of Uber eats. Im a sucker for a buffalo chicken wrap! Well I was surely disappointed with my delivery from this restaurant, not from the delivery service. I ordered a buffalo chicken wrap with fries and a small pizza with pepperoni and olives. The fries are so greasy, cold, limp and undercooked. The wrap is soggy, tastes like Caesar instead of ranch, chicken breading is soggy and not from the buffalo sauce, the bacon is so chewy I question if it was even cooked. Thankfully I got a small pizza for dinner, because that ended up being lunch. It wasn’t great either, was pretty salty - not from the olives either (I’m Greek salty olives is the norm). I might order here again to see if this was a one off… but will stick with pizza only… maybe try the wings. Just disappointing for $35 ish worth of food - not including tip and service fees for delivery! Paid nearly $50 and half the meal is in the trash.

December 4, 2024 on Google

Tried Carson’s for the first time yesterday. Ordered a 10” Chicago deep dish and was blown away at how good it was! The crust was flavourful and sturdy enough to keep such a massive pie structurally sound while eating a slice. The cheese and sauce were delicious plentiful which is no surprise when it comes to Chicago deep dish. The guy running the place told us there’s a pound of cheese in the 10”! Really glad I found out about this place because there’s not many places in Hamilton/ Niagara that serves Chicago deep dish. Highly recommend checking this place out! I’ll definitely be hitting this place up again.

November 18, 2024 on Google

Small takeout Pizzeria very very friendly stuff. The New York style pizza was good. The Chicago style was also good. Just the parmesan overkilled it. The staff was friendly and accommodating

October 4, 2024 on Google

Me and my boyfriend love Carson pizza I found out about them through my brother and end up trying them and it was amazing my kids and family love it especially there wings You don’t find good wings around Niagara anywhere anymore , their alway respect and sweet to my family and even had us try their jerk chicken wings was their own and it taste yummy but I like their honey hot the best ! Give it a try if you haven’t And meet the nice safe feel welcomed

September 17, 2024 on Google

We have been wanting to try Carson’s Pizza for a while now. This past weekend we finally got the chance. Honestly, I don’t know why we waited so long. The pizza was great, we tried a Chicago deep dish and a regular style pizza, both were amazing. The toppings on both were fresh and plentiful, as was the cheese. The sauce was great, well seasoned and a good amount. The crust was very good, even throughout the pizza and had a great taste, texture and consistency. The prices were reasonable compared to other similar pizza places in the area. The service was great and both pizzas came out on time. We were skeptical at first as there were mixed reviews, but just goes to show you can’t believe everything you read on the internet. Definitely will be back in the future and I would definitely recommend you try out Carson’s pizza on your next pizza adventure.

August 20, 2024 on Google

Im new to the area and was looking for some tasty pizza. The other photos online look good but out pizza said otherwise. It does look good but the pizza was very soggy and fell apart quick. Got the Monday special with wings, and a large margarita pizza.

June 17, 2024 on Google

Update: I still have not gone back but they suggested I contact them via email. Even after I tried to discuss my issues twice the day of the order. It's good to see that businesses only care about seeing negative reviews effect them rather than fix the issue when it arises. Original review: After being referred to Carson's for how good their deep dish is and pizza in general, I can say I won't order again. The two ordering systems they use (besides phone) are horrendous and the staff blamed that for my order being incorrect. Ordering ahead to make sure the food was hot and ready for a night shift of 9 people eating at work, planning to pickup between 6:45-6:55pm (which the confirmation text and emails said it would be ready at) only to get a confirmation at 6:23pm it was ready. 20 minutes ahead of time without notice. Needless to say, the food was cold when it was brought to work for our dinner. Besides that, the 4lbs of wings (that came without sauce because of an ordering issue) were the lightest 4lbs of wings I've ever seen. Their deep dish pizza has almost zero cheese, the biggest and most expensive part of deep dish pizzas, making it overpriced and just sauce mostly. Spending $180 on the food pictured was just upsetting. Ordering ahead of time to make sure it was hot and ready and having my pickup time changed much further ahead. Not one of the 9 people that ate the food that night said they would order there, which is very upsetting as they came highly recommended.

September 24, 2023 on Google